317 Comments

Thank you for adding your voice to those of your MSNBC colleagues on the Ronna McDaniel hiring by NBC. Host after host starting on Morning Joe and throughout the evening tonight voiced solidarity with the notion that a conservative voice on the Network is fine, but a liar is not. A different political opinion is one thing but an accessory to election fraud is not OK. Not just unwelcome, she is unacceptable to the MSNBC team and, most importantly, to MSNBC viewers.

Expand full comment

Rachel Madow said that the MSNBC brass signed off on McDaniel's hiring when they were informed of it, and it was only when the staff were told of it and threw a fit with their bosses that they went back and made a statement of opposition. I have to believe that the MSNBC people have to be wondering about whom they're working for. This is a very troubling development.

Expand full comment

And … as Lawrence O’Donnell pointed out last night, some of the NBC managers who made this decision weren’t even born before Watergate. If not an outright corrupt move to protect themselves and the benefits that go with positions of tremendous power and influence, this decision, it seems, is a move to appease Trump world. Which will never work, especially if T wins the Whitehouse. Trump is not a politician; he’s a gangster. And so is Ronna.

Expand full comment

Trump will never peacefully get to the White House.

Expand full comment

You are right. He and his supporters have told us so. Why do we keep questioning what they have told us.,,,

Expand full comment

He will never get to the White House. We won't allow it, one way or another.

Expand full comment

Is it news to anyone that in major media organizations, the "suits" tend to be richer, whiter, more male, and a lot less liberal than those doing the actual work?

Expand full comment

Carrie Budoff Brown did the hiring. Has she attempted to explain herself yet?

Expand full comment

Does anyone think she did it entirely on her own, i.e., without consulting anybody?

Expand full comment

These folks are career oriented to the point of destroying the ground they stand on not understanding that the whole enterprise of respectable news and news opinion depends on presenting and taking the side of the truth and maintaining credibility and reputation. Somehow this had morphed into presenting whatever in the name of presenting "bothsides". It's as if equal they disregarded morality and were unconcerned about how vulnerable people can be especially when they trust a source, a powerful source. Without the anchors revolt, they would let things slide further.

With Trump the media print and online, and after complaints, started calling a lie a lie, a falsehood a falsehood. They had to be told this so lost they became?

That McDaniel continued to rationalize and defend herself and her part in the insurrection was unconscionable; that was passed over. The anchors shamed the powers that be, and subtly, in concert, used their power. Let it be a lesson and an example that many in the "biz" still need. It reflected on the best and they revolted.

Expand full comment

My sense is that those at the top are generally business people, not journalists, and that's the way they think, act, and react. The journalists, at least the good ones, are always walking a tightrope between the paymasters and their commitment to their own trade.

Expand full comment

It does not make business sense to have those at the top foreign to what the company stands for, it's reputation, history, mission. It's a responsibility. Does it lead for the good, or succomb to money interests alone? As well what good journalism is about even if one does not have training in it.. which they should.

Expand full comment

Which is why substack is so good. But we are channeling and are channeled.

Expand full comment

Good point. We haven’t heard the end of that story yet.

Expand full comment

Ronna is out.

Expand full comment

Good. Haven’t seen a link yet.

Expand full comment

Ari Melber just read the announcement from the head of NBC programming (Cesar ?). He explained the “group think,” recognized the outcry, apologized to anchors. I feel certain his statement will be read each hour this evening.

Expand full comment

Every news organization - big & small - has now released the news! Thank heavens NBC found the fortitude to do the right thing and cut Ronna - another liar like tfg - loose.

Expand full comment

I'm not sure it's an entirely troubling development. The fact that brass signed off on it is absolutely troubling but the response from MSNBC and NBC staff plus the inundation of emails from so many of us on substack and from elsewhere, causing her hiring to be rescinded, is heartening. May brass have learned something from this, most particularly the message that we out here are watching and letting them know when they "go astray".

Expand full comment

Judith, thanks for letting the NBC brass know of your disapproval. Among the lessons I hope they’ve learned is that they need to watch their own network a little more often. If they had done that before they made that, um, ill considered decision, they would have known Ronna McDaniel was over the line.

Expand full comment

They are working for people who lost their sense of the importance of integrity and responsibility to the public mind.

Expand full comment

Rachel said it best!

Expand full comment

Lawrence O'Donnell also did a good job of explaining why he wouldn't interview her or any liar.

Expand full comment

Nichole Wallace was also brilliant as always; she led her A block with a severe condemnation of the hire.

Expand full comment

Is there a video link somewhere?

Expand full comment

I'm sure you can find it on utube.

Expand full comment

Hey NBC, if Steve Bannon and Roger Stone sanitized their spiels and tidied up on Linkedin would you hire them? There are not two sides to lies and treason. Full stop.

Expand full comment

She's unacceptable in the news business. Shame on NBC.

And I too am grateful for Rachel Maddows show last night. That we have seen scum like drumpf before, but they never had a party machinery, and media behind them, with the exception perhaps of the lord "father" Coughlin.

Her description of the en masse rejection of MSNBC staff was epic.

Expand full comment

Rachel was on 🔥

In Nicolle’s coverage she interviewed Tim Snyder who said, “So this is like a trial run for NBC and everyone else to say okay, we're going to practice appeasing a dictator and then when it comes, we'll be better at it."

In his On Tyrann 20 Lessons, number 1 is “Never Obey In Advance”

Expand full comment

Synder's Book "On Tyranny: 20 Lessons from the 20th Century" is required reading for all of us. Good news: it concise: not a long read but a powerful read.

Expand full comment

This book is excellent! Rachel recommended it in 2017, shortly after Trump was elected. Little book; quick read -- but then I've gone back and back and back to re-read parts as the book sickeningly and increasingly resonates with what is happening to our country.

Expand full comment

Yes! MSNBC hosts did exactly what had to be done! Kudos to all of them for speaking the truth!

Expand full comment

Nicolle Wallace on Deadline Whitehouse did a great job as well. She had Yale historian Timithy Snyder the author of "On Tyranny" on to discuss the hire and explain why it works in with the autocratic designs of the conservatives. It was no holds barred and great.

Expand full comment

Rachel Madow, Chuck Todd, and the other hosts did a great service when standing up against Ronna McDaniel. If you would like to chime in, the email for NBC is nbcshows@nbcuni.com. I've expressed my displeasure, and will not be buying anything advertised on NBC until she's gone.

Expand full comment

I wrote to protest Ronna's hiring by NBC. I stated that NBC is now in the same basket as FOX. I can't think of a worse insult.

Expand full comment

Me, too! Feels good!!

Expand full comment

Yes - write, write, write people! I also wrote to protest both yesterday and today. I hope NBC realizes the utter humility and hardships many of our families endured to pack up settled lives and moved to free themselves of constantly living in fear, and brought themselves here to establish a better system of governance. The link is posted - please take advantage of that and send in a note!

Expand full comment

NBC News plans to drop ex RNC-chair RONNA McDANIEL as a paid contributor,” Puck’s Dylan Byers

Expand full comment

It was never going to be easy to watch Trump's trials unfold but it was good to hear Judge Merchan hold Trump and his attorney accountable. It's so reassuring to have you provide the facts and an analysis of the law that we can rely on.

Expand full comment

Does anyone see the irony in the trial starting on April 15…get your popcorn ready!

Expand full comment

He’s not unique in his stupid entitlement but he’s stepped a little closer than he should have to the edge of the cliff by trying to strip us of our democracy. Is he thinking as I hope - that running for president was the worst single decision of his lifetime?

Expand full comment

That would require him to have a piece of equipment he has never demonstrated he possesses - a brain.

Expand full comment

Agree 100% TCinLA

Expand full comment

And the irony is he never wanted to be president. He just wanted his own network.

Expand full comment

I doubt he thinks it was a bad decision. If he wins all of these Federal charges disappear. He will figure out some way to tank the Georgia case. My concern is how is he planning to get those electoral votes? He isn't campaigning for broad support; he is limiting the people he wants voting for him.

Expand full comment

Some captive nerd genius in Moscow is drawing up the numbers needed in each precinct in the USA on Election Day right now. His traitor techs here are worming their way into voting systems in every state where it counts.

BUT if we vote in big enough numbers it won’t matter.

Expand full comment

The only problem with that is that massive turnout in blue states won't matter in the electoral college count, the only count that "counts."

Expand full comment

And isn’t that a bunch of BS??!! TC, in my heart of hearts, I feel there will be a landslide victory for Biden-Harris. I am going to keep thinking that. In the meantime, I am sending a solemn request to whatever or whomever is listening to me, that Biden stays healthy.

Expand full comment

As I've said before, I think Kamala Harris would be a force to be reckoned with should she need to step up to the presidency. Marlene, I do not know where you are from in CA, but I've seen her work in the Bay Area. Can't say everyone likes Kamala, but no politician is uniquely popular. I think Kamala is being "Hilloried." She is an understudy. And she will listen to those around her.

Expand full comment

I'm tired of hearing people trash her.

Expand full comment

Kamala will be the law and order president, should she step in. And boy-oh-boy will we need law and order.

Expand full comment

Louise, I am, in fact, in the Bay Area and we love her. She’s tough and now very experienced because Biden has sought to give her the reins she needs in case something happens (Heaven forbid!) to him.

Expand full comment

Actually she’s being racist’d & misogynist’d. She’s receiving a double whammy. She is more than qualified to be president. Moreover she’s been cris crossing the globe doing international policy.

Expand full comment

Kamala has the basic problem Hillary had, she’s a woman. That she is also a woman of color makes two strikes against her. She also is a woman of high intelligence and knowledge, she would be an excellent Commander in Chief.

Expand full comment

Hear! Hear!

Expand full comment

Yes indeed!!

Expand full comment

I think so too! I hope we are right! I worry for his safety especially if desperation takes over. Too many.crazies?

Expand full comment

But Kamala will hold back the wild horses!

Expand full comment

I’m listening Marlene…..I’m giving it some thought….OK, I’m done thinking and I’m good with it.

Expand full comment

I hope we have learned from the 2016 election and keep our eyes on Russia trying to steal the 2024 election. I don't trust the repugs or the Russians (they are the same)

Expand full comment

"Some captive nerd genius in Moscow is drawing up the numbers needed in each precinct in the USA on Election Day right now. His traitor techs here are worming their way into voting systems in every state where it counts."

I think this is the sort of bogus nonsense that the MAGA-QANON conspiracy mobs spout ... I don't think it's necessary on here where rational people reside; the electoral machinery is much more hardened than that.

Expand full comment

I was stretching things admittedly - though unless I’m wrong (and I don’t believe I am) his idiot troops are plotting some cretinous level schemes.

Expand full comment

He is certainly making sure that a lot of marginal states are doing their very best to (illegally) suppress the votes of those who would most likely vote for President Biden.

Expand full comment

Seeing it in real time every day. Their tactics to sew up the Attorney Generals position in those states gets the hairs up on the back of my neck.

Still we have advocates who work to thwart them (like Democracy Docket) - it’s a chess game.

Expand full comment

Fortunately, they are idiots. About 277 are doing time in the pokey and another 133 or so are wearing decorative ankle bracelets. This does not represent good planning on their part. I guess idiots don’t plan very well - which should inure to our benefit if push comes to shove.

Expand full comment

True - reliably moronic .

(I just worry that they’re armed morons). But yes.

Expand full comment

It isn't much of a stretch, Patris.

Expand full comment

It's not that the"electoral machinery" is the problem. Russian disguised Misinfo and disinfo online was viewed by millions of Americans in the last 2 elections. Plus , we now have several online fake news orgs from Russia disguised as American news orgs. If they only convince 5% of the people who view their propaganda, may be enuf to change the result in swing States . AS a former supporter of ACLU, I'm sad to say that their view of freedom of the press is so extreme that they are fine with Russia online election propaganda. I changed my support to Democracy Docket and ProPublica.

Expand full comment

The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact (NPVIC) is a contract among cooperating states such that when they have a collective group representing a majority of the electoral votes (currently 270) by July before the next Presidential election, they will be activated. The compact is an agreement to assign all of the group's electoral votes to the candidate who wins the national popular vote. As of March 2024, states completing the process of joining represent 205 electoral votes; states having partially completed the process represent another 101 electoral votes (source: Wikipedia). Getting to 270 votes by July (4 months from now) seems unlikely, but it could very well be in effect for 2028. The NPVIC would leave the Electoral College in place but would render it moot.

Expand full comment

Thank you for the explanation! I knew the details years ago, but forgot them.

Expand full comment

We pooh-poohed the idea of Russia attempting to subvert our elections, too. How did that work out?

Expand full comment

"I doubt he thinks it was a bad decision. If he wins all of these Federal charges disappear."

I agree he had no choice but to run this time ... but for my money the worst decision he made was to run for president in 2016. If he had not - none of these charges would now be confronting him. He could be playing golf every day and making bogus millions.

He claims that he has been treated worse than any previous president, and apart from those who were assassinated in office, I actually think he's right. He's brought all sorts of mayhem upon himself because he stepped out of his grift zone into politics. More fool him.

Expand full comment

My guess is he’ll never regret running and winning the presidency. He got to be on TV for five years straight (six now? Seven?). I think celebrity and attention were always at the core of Trump‘s soul… if you can call that a soul. Which, now that I think of it, you can’t. I hereby expunge my first use of the word soul. Totally redacted. Blacked out. Never even existed OK?

Expand full comment

He won't win Penny. He would already be in jail had he not declared his campaign for the 2024 presidency - it has been part of his delay plan.

Expand full comment

I agree with you!

Expand full comment

Love this substack when folks agree with me:)) 💙

He will be in jail after the hush money trial. Then his minions can vote for him while he's in the can and the fence-sitters will have a decision to make.

Expand full comment

He’s going to cheat; that’s been the plan all along. Delay the trials, win the election by any means necessary, problem solved.

Expand full comment

Patris, he is not thinking at all. He is desperately attempting to avoid jail. But he will be in jail for the remainder of his life.

Expand full comment

He will never see the inside of a prison. All of the big lawyers including Joyce have said as much. Moreover, you can be a felon and still be president. There is nothing in our constitution to stop it. Plus he’s still considered a first time offender.

Expand full comment

It totally was.

Expand full comment

Don Poorleone has experienced the chickens coming home to roost. In the early 1990s in Connecticut, Trump visited Hartford to try and receive approval to build a casino. But our then governor, Lowell Wicker and my friend and Hartford mayor, Carrie Saxon Perry, were already working an exclusive deal with our Native tribes to which Trump mused, “They don’t look like Indians to me.”

Well Donald Trump, you don’t look like a billionaire to me.

(I have my press credentials and intend to be in court writing about it.)

Billkatz@substract.com

Expand full comment

Thank you, Joyce for lining things up for us. Also, was very happy to see MSNBC newscasters call out Ronna Romney McDaniels over the air and in real time. She is not to be trusted and obviously, neither are the execs at NBC. They too, may be complicit for all we know. I loved it when Lawrence said if he had an opportunity to interview her, which he said he won’t, he would ask her why she succumbed to what Trump wanted. That was to remove her maiden name when she was RNC chair. Gotta love Lawrence!

Expand full comment

Reading the verbatim of the Access tape leaves me shaking my head and wondering how did tfg get beyond that.

Expand full comment

Because a lot of people (men) out there admire it, wish they were as rich & famous, and would like to be able to do the same thing?

Expand full comment

Cargill, bingo, the curtain got pulled back

Expand full comment

Very many

Expand full comment

Because you have to be a moron to be a Fundiescum.

Expand full comment

Brushed off by the cheerleader moms in the suburbs as “locker room talk.” And since the primary objective of Maga is to own the Libs, irritate the libs, annoy the libs… while being entertaining, is the whole game for the Maga people. The more outrageous the better from their point of view. And that’s why if the fat slob is still alive in November, he’ll get millions of votes. The thirst for fascism in this country is on a different shelf altogether.

Expand full comment

Watching Morning Joe, Nicolle, Ari, Maddow (right now cause I nodded off before the end of Ari) flat out say No to having Rona on makes me realize just how much integrity the on air people really have unlike Fox or Newsmax. I don’t see Rona being around much longer cause we the viewers and the biggest names on MSNBC won’t allow it. I would even venture to say that the person that hired her is on shaky ground. Notice TFG hasn’t said anything about Rona? Cause she could promote the big lie for him. Everyone has stuck together and that’s what we need to defeat this scourge on our country of the party of Trump. The GOP died in 2017 and although a few stragglers are left it won’t rise out of the ashes like a phoenix. Those stragglers are without a party.

Expand full comment

I'm hoping another couple of Congressional GOP Reps throw in the towel so the Dems can have a majority before the election. Jen Psaki asked Nancy Pelosi on last Sunday's show if it were possible that Hakim Jeffries would become speaker before the election and Pelosi would not say, spoke of her support for Jeffries, then quietly agreed. That would be something, the GOP imploding.

Expand full comment

All it’s gonna take is 2 more defections.

Expand full comment

You know, Nancy has a tremendous amount of patience. That’s something I should really learn from her. I guess it comes after raising so many children.

Expand full comment

We're working on it in CD4. Ken Bucks seat can go D

Expand full comment

I respect your opinion but once he is gone in 2026 or 27 because appeals won’t be decided until then, the rest of the Red State Rs will try to make believe he never happened by never again mentioning his name in public. I suspect their party will be weaker on the national scene but they will continue to dominate in much of South and Midwest in State legislatures and Governors. However, younger voters will be in the majority in 2030 and thereafter on the Federal level and battleground states! The dichotomy will intensify!

Expand full comment

He won’t be gone unless he’s in prison or dead. Even in prison he’ll be running his con game with his cult.

Expand full comment

I still want to see him in a wheelchair drooling into his lap. Still trying to smear on his makeup.

Does he wear it sweating at golf?

Expand full comment

Ira, do you think the younger Maga voters have already been indoctrinated into “brown shirts”? My thought is that Gen Z’ers will over power them. At least, that is my hope.

Expand full comment

Young conservative AI experts will figure out how to build a new opposition party to the Dems. Best I can tell, the people most interested in devoting their lives to money view the Trump years not as a disaster, but as a tremendous business opportunity for the future.

Expand full comment

“We cannot let these people pretend it never happened.” This is exactly what NBC is doing..

"Nicolle Wallace, discussing NBC's hiring of Ronna McDaniel, reads on @MSNBC this except from Timothy Snyder's 'On Tyranny':

"Most of the power of authoritarianism is freely given. In times like these, individuals think ahead about what a more repressive government will want, and then offer themselves without being asked. A citizen who adapts in this way is teaching power what it can do." NBC is practicing appeasing a Dictator with McDaniel..This must remain in the news cycle and continue to pressure NBC until they dump McDaniel..It is unacceptable!

Expand full comment