358 Comments
User's avatar
Carrie Maxwell's avatar

I'm so fucking tired of Donald Trump and his cult member traitors to America. He should already be in prison for the rest of his life. See also the 147 MOC who voted to overturn the 2020 presidential election based on fraudulent slates of electors (that they knew about beforehand) to send a message to other people planning to run for office that they cannot get away with these crimes. I cannot have this crap go on for the rest of my life. I'm 52 and see no end in sight to this dangerous madness.

Expand full comment
Mimi Champlin's avatar

I'm more than 20 years older, and by gawd, I'd buy you a beer and let you vent. I'm also sick to death of his mental illness and how it calls to millions of others in this country.

Expand full comment
Carrie Maxwell's avatar

Thanks Mimi. I'd ask for a Midori Sour instead of a bear. Wish we could hang out IRL already.

Expand full comment
Mimi Champlin's avatar

Your choice on the booze. I am pretty allergic most of my life, so I buy a beer and get my two sips in and call it good.

Carrie, it would be an honor and a privilege.

I am reminded, by nothing at all apparent of a quote from Katherine Hepburn, when asked about why she didn't drink, "Because stone cold sober, I am absolutely fascinating."

I offer this answer to anyone who might enjoy using it lol!!!

Expand full comment
Carrie Maxwell's avatar

Thanks. We should find a way for all of us Joyce fans to do meet-ups in different regions of the country. Where do you live? I'm in Chicago.

Expand full comment
Gail Adams VA/FL's avatar

I’m in.

Expand full comment
Diana-Sedona's avatar

I love the idea of a get together! 🥂 I’m in Sedona AZ.

Expand full comment
Linda Weide's avatar

Yes. I am friends with a Joyce fan. He introduced me to Joyce because he knew I read Heather. I'm in Chicago too, at least part of the time.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Aug 7, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Carrie Maxwell's avatar

Got it. I wish this country wasn't so big distance-wise so we had easier access to each other.

Expand full comment
Barbara Jo Krieger's avatar

Mimi, Your inserting the Hepburn quote, which I had never heard or read (and I’ve heard and read a lot), brought to mind a belief I’ve always carried—that the gutsy, highly vocal women who, in the 70s, led the challenge to prescribed roles and rules, stood on the shoulders of the likes of Katherine Hepburn. On another matter, I would be delighted to be part of a group-meet on whatever platform works.

Expand full comment
Ally House (Oregon)'s avatar

Count me in for this!

Expand full comment
Bryan Sean McKown's avatar

I am in Oregon City.

Expand full comment
Karen RN's avatar

I’m in Hood River, OR

Expand full comment
Ally House (Oregon)'s avatar

I think Karen RN is up your way as well, Counselor. We just might have to have a get-together!

Expand full comment
Karen RN's avatar

I’m in Oregon.

Expand full comment
Charlie Austin's avatar

Ohio. Columbus to be exact.

Expand full comment
Annie D Stratton's avatar

Golly, lots of folks here in Oregon! I want to go visit some old high school friends there, would love to mix in a gathering too!

Expand full comment
Valere's avatar

I Will love using the quote. And May I be the designated driver? I feel we will all meet one day.

Expand full comment
Mimi Champlin's avatar

Sure, I love not having to drive anymore!

Expand full comment
Annie D Stratton's avatar

I think I might be joining you, unwillingly. My car isn't going to pass inspection this year, and I'm not comfortable driving the beast as it is. Looking for a decent small car but so is everyone else, so unless I stumble across something within the next few weeks, I'll be carless in VT. Yikes.

Expand full comment
Karen RN's avatar

Can I please join you two? I will buy!

Expand full comment
Carrie Maxwell's avatar

Yes please.

Expand full comment
Erica's avatar

We're like a virtual book club. I'm in NYC.

Expand full comment
Margee Cooper's avatar

74 years old here and I with you!

Expand full comment
Mimi Champlin's avatar

Hey Margee!

Expand full comment
Diana-Sedona's avatar

I'm 70 and feel the same. I was so hoping for some peace after the 2020 election. How wrong I was!! Yes the orange one must be held accountable and all the elected reps and senators who continue to go along with his b.s. must be voted out and held accountable, too. We all deserve a peaceful nation!

Expand full comment
Tutone's avatar

Exit stage right 👏

Expand full comment
Elisabeth Iler's avatar

Carrie, I hear you! But there are so many more of us than them. Humpty Dumpty is in shards on the grounds where he fell from his wall and the legal process is now gaining momentum. I agree with you about the 147 MOC who are basically insurrectionists. Throw them the hell out at the polls. Remember, democracy is not a spectator sport. I’m 74 and ready to fight this crap til my last day....with you, Gal!

Expand full comment
Doug Smith's avatar

Elisabeth you hearten me! I'm 71 and am nowhere near giving in to the bullyism that is trying to destroy our democracy. Agreed that we must remember that there are so many more of us than the ones who have allowed themselves to be cult followers. Putin must have grand satisfaction at how a portion of our nation is being eaten out from within by those who slavishly follow his orange puppet operative. Like a flesh eating virus. This too shall pass, but at what cost? Courage and actions of average citizens is what is going to save our nation. Thank God I'm seeing young people are engaging in saving democracy as well. I'm seeing a glimmer of light with our judicial system.

Expand full comment
SweetieP's avatar

Same age here too, in Virginia. Maybe Joyce should start an annual gathering with meetings of the minds or zoom, just not in Florida or Texas. I just can't for the life of me understand how so many are entranced by Trump. I read that his followers don't read anything and just accept what he says. Do you think that is the case? I don't know how anyone could witness him and not walk away disgusted by his hate and lies. He's dumb but so evil. He's very good at working the legal system and getting people to do what he wants. I just don't get it.

Expand full comment
Sherry Wolf's avatar

I don't get it either. I recently had a conversation with my MAGA brother. He's a smart, well educated man. I asked him why he likes TFG... he said two things that are so wrong that you had to pick me up off the floor.... He's honest and he's not in politics for the money, but for the ego. (I said "it's both") I can't stop thinking about this. He parrots all of MAGA talking points. His answer to the documents case is "everyone does it". You can't counter a mind set like that. He's always been a "my way is the only truth" kind of guy. I'm just ranting... thanks for listening

Expand full comment
Diana-Sedona's avatar

My father, a Pearl Harbor survivor, was all in for trump right up until he died 3 yrs ago. To say we had a few heated discussions is an understatement. Fox News was on every waking hour at his house and at all his friends' homes too. Many of these people were well educated but were all sucked in by Fox News. Went to dinner with my father and a dozen of his friends shortly before he died. Talk about spoiling a perfectly good meal. The same talking points your brother spews were part of the conversation that night. As I've said probably said a 1000 times or more, I will never understand.

Expand full comment
Nancy Lent Lanoue's avatar

I try to articulate my thoughts on who and what exerted enough force for the lurch in the direction of authoritarianism. ( yes, I know about the frog). But it noticeably picked up around 2015. No alarms over photos of Rex Tillerson getting a medal from P’tin. Manafort and Russians lurking in every corner. Not to mention the Olympics in Moscow and Miss Universe seemingly back-to-back. The Mueller Report was too late. It drew a lot of eyeballs but Barr put a stop to that. Will we ever know the depth of sedition and betrayal let loose by the “useful idiot(s)”. The Orange One couldn’t have been the brains behind the “swerve” toward fascism. My head is swimming.

Expand full comment
Claudia McKelway's avatar

Same age, same thoughts, same gratitude toward the young people!

Expand full comment
L P Inness's avatar

same age here, same thoughts, too. I believed all the protesting I did in the 60s and 70s would have yielded better results... I'm in East TN and would love to join a meet-up!

Expand full comment
Maryanne Shanahan's avatar

Pushing 80 and full of the same determination and resolve! Been at this since my late teens, every step of the way. Whenever I am even remotely dispirited, each of you within Joyce and Heather's letters lift me up and give me hope. And, I would be happy to drive the rental van. Being with all of you in person would lift my spirits without liquid spirits!! NC here.

Expand full comment
SCS - Michigan's avatar

They made a MOCkery of our democratic system and still are!

Expand full comment
Diana-Sedona's avatar

MOCkery! That’s awesome!!! 👏🏻 👏🏻👏🏻

Expand full comment
@GPE (BlueSky) - WNY via CO&NJ's avatar

I see what you did there!

Expand full comment
Kenneth James's avatar

Seventy-one years old, and counting. I'm with you. I lost patience with Trump supporters years ago. It's an absolute non-starter. As someone who has studied the American founding and the Constitution, I have no grace for these people and their claims to being true patriots. I don't give a damn about their reasons or their supposed grievances. No matter the circumstances, you don't hire the devil to do your bidding.

The only way I can stay sane is to not let this stuff be the only item on my mental menu. I balance it with other more edifying pursuits, with work, regular exercise, and with things and people that give my life joy and meaning. And if that fails to do the trick, I may try micro-dosing. Whatever. I'm open.

Does anyone in here know how to perform voodoo and black magic? I'm open to anything at this point. I just don't want to be the one to hold that stupid little Trump doll.

Expand full comment
Elisabeth Iler's avatar

🤣🤣🤣

Expand full comment
Gus Koch (GA)'s avatar

Kenneth, it doesn't work. I wish it did....

Expand full comment
Rita Parker's avatar

I'm 75, and I agree 100%.

Expand full comment
Linda Weide's avatar

I don't think Trump needs to be thrown into prison right now, but a Mar-a-lago or NYC home detention complete with ankle monitor, and the admonishment that any media posting he makes needs to be cleared by an impartial person or committee (I prefer the latter because it takes longer and will be perceived as more fair), to make sure that he is not revealing secrets or threatening anyone. Of course that means that he is not able to travel for his campaign, but he can talk, just not to threaten anyone. If that is a necessary part of his campaign too bad.

Expand full comment
JA's avatar

An ankle bracelet will not curb his tongue! Tape his mouth!

This Judge is not one to fool around with. Maybe Trump will eventually catch on?

Expand full comment
Marcia Sharkey's avatar

Exactly how I’m feeling! This horrid man is impossibly exhausting. I pray this judge will shut him up!!

Expand full comment
TCinLA's avatar

We've all been cursed by a non-ancient, non-Chinese guy to live our lives in "interesting times."

Expand full comment
Gregg Barak's avatar

You are so correct, however, it will all come to end only the appeals will take us through 2025. Fortunately getting the GOP nomination will result in a landslide victory for the Democrats and May very well explode the Republican Party in the process.

Expand full comment
Doug Smith's avatar

Can you imagine being a sane Republican who sees through all of this? Someone like Cheney, Romney, Kinzinger, Flake, and a few others, as well as average citizens? It must be like deer with their eyes in the headlights, watching paralyzed, as their party destroys itself from within. If a vote were taken today, more than 81 million would vote against the orange toad and his swamp creatures.

Expand full comment
SweetieP's avatar

Why do they keep reporting that Trump and Biden are tied? It just doesn't seem possible. Are they just lying to us?

Expand full comment
Kathleen Fernandez's avatar

I don't trust polling.

Expand full comment
Annie D Stratton's avatar

Yes, actually. Or selectively reporting, which is pretty much the same. Big Media has a short memory that gets stuck on things. Too young reporters with too shallow a sense of what journalism is supposed to be, caught up in a corporate profit-driven mode. But it is up to us to take the initiative, step back and see where else to get our news and information. There are plenty of good sources out there. I keep sharing mine, and would again, but rigth now I need to eat food. This is not an option. Hope other folks jump in with some suggestions (So ok, Propublica, Politico, your favorite substack authors. Believe it or not, the Guardian does some pretty decent coverage of American political (and other) news. There's more. Gotta go.

Expand full comment
Susan Burgess's avatar

I’m sure those numbers are wrong and swayed purposefully. I can’t bring myself to believe they are tied. At all.

Expand full comment
Gregg Barak's avatar

I thought I had responded earlier. The polls are not lies. However, when candidates are w/i 10 points you can find a poll that says they are even— the week before Biden was up five. But none of these polls mean much of anything until the GOP convention in July 2024. Should the alleged or convicted criminal be the nomination— it will be all over for Trump who will lose in a landslide much like Barry Goldwater did. And, if we are lucky the trapped GOP will implode in the process.

Expand full comment
Annie D Stratton's avatar

I so hope. But I've learned the hard way that what seems inevitable is not necessarily so.

Expand full comment
Gregg Barak's avatar

Nobody said anything was inevitable.

Expand full comment
Carol Jacobson's avatar

I am 76 years old and I cannot believe that I am having to go thru this bullshit as I near the end of my life in a country that used to be a great one. How is it that America has devolved into this hot mess? I will never understand how that orange anus ever got elected in the first place or how so many malleable minds can be conned into a cult like he has created.

Expand full comment
Annie D Stratton's avatar

Carol, for some of us, America has never really been a great country. Many of my ancestors died so yours could live comfortably and in a state of ignorance. Trump didn't invent this. It's been built in for a long time.

Expand full comment
Janey's avatar

It is exhausting, but I send out a wish almost every day, that I will just live long enough to see his ass in jail. My uncle died last year, at 91, and he was bummed to know he was going to miss the end of all this! We will prevail.

Expand full comment
Erica's avatar

Same! I've lived in Europe before, and if next year turns out to be worse, living parents or no, I'm looking at how to move back since I can work from anywhere. Nowhere is a panacea, but at least I wouldn't also have to worry about guns (and I live in NYC!).

Expand full comment
SB's avatar

After that last threatening post about him coming to get you: Any other defendant would find his derrière in jail. I understand and appreciate Jack Smith’s judicious timing but we really need to see some accountability very soon. Speaking of which....we really need, and I mean REALLY need to see these trials televised. The country must see this otherwise Trump will just manipulate the media. I’m soooooooooooo fed up. 😵‍💫🤢

Expand full comment
Tutone's avatar

45 put the American people at risk Re J6 and we deserve to see every minute of this trial.

Expand full comment
Martha Berzon's avatar

Thank you, Joyce, for being in this both for and with us. Your perspectives are invaluable.

Expand full comment
Edward Lehman's avatar

Glad we are all here and for Joyce’s insights. Feels like a fraught time, but also one where the truth starts to win out.

Expand full comment
STEVE HOLCOMBE's avatar

I'm a lawyer. Former ADA in Oklahoma from a long time ago. I lean heavily on Joyce for staying up-to-date and oriented regarding all of these cases and proceedings.

Expand full comment
Mimi Champlin's avatar

It's a LOT, isn't it? I dislike the delay to get to this point and simultaneously appreciate that to win in court against this literal monster requires precision and masterful focus plus attention to every single detail. I do not envy the weight on Jack Smith's shoulders, or any of the prosecutors in all the many states in which he is indicted.

Still and all, I remain slightly nauseous at the unending pictures of this human who is so blindly followed by masses of voters and so very much the banner for the wish to destroy our country's government.

Expand full comment
DW's avatar

I was heartened when he was appointed… A former prosecutor in the Hague… Doesn’t get more serious than that

Expand full comment
SPW's avatar

Jack Smith is definitely prosecuting trump war crimes against the Constitution. trump swore an oath to defend and protect it against all enemies, foreign and domestic. He sold us out to our adversaries so is being tried as what he proved himself to be. Mr Smith’s appointment was an inspired choice.

Expand full comment
Mimi Champlin's avatar

Yes!!

Expand full comment
Louis Giglio's avatar

Is he really ‘human’?

Expand full comment
Mimi Champlin's avatar

I know, and yes. He's one who reminds us that within nature there are mistakes which can't be returned to nprmal function. These kinds can only be isolated from the ability to harm others

Expand full comment
Tutone's avatar

Make him wear a dunces hat and sit in the corner of the courtroom.

Expand full comment
ira lechner's avatar

Joyce: another non criminal lawyer here; can you explain how he will refute these personal charges without taking the stand? And do you think they will risk putting him on the stand for publicity purposes?

Expand full comment
Gail Adams VA/FL's avatar

He can’t, and they won’t. The aim is chaos.

Expand full comment
Tutone's avatar

45 will do everything he can to create a spectacle as a martyr because he knows it will raise millions for him. OMG the irony.

Expand full comment
ira lechner's avatar

Except going to jail; he doesn’t know who he is dealing with here! We will see!

Expand full comment
Mimi Champlin's avatar

Two GREAT questions

Expand full comment
ira lechner's avatar

Thanks!

Expand full comment
ira lechner's avatar

Related to Yale prof?

Expand full comment
Claudia McKelway's avatar

Retired lawyer here but I stayed on the civil litigation side; Joyce’s writing is so informative and helpful in this orange morass.

Expand full comment
Susan Burgess's avatar

I feel a strong sense of the dawning of a new day with this latest indictment. And Fani is in the wings to add weight to that.

Expand full comment
Karen Rousseau's avatar

So many tangential thoughts. Don’t know why this feels so personal, but it just does. My husband and I followed everything from its awful beginnings, Art joining in on television panel discussions like he would coach a televised basketball game. Then he became ill last summer and passed away in April - man, he would love to have known it is raining indictments at last. Another example of being in this together. Deepest condolences, Joyce, and also, deepest thanks.

Expand full comment
Valere's avatar

I am sorry for your loss Karen.

Expand full comment
Norma Lee Kerns Barnhart's avatar

Karen, I am sorry for your loss. Maybe Art knows about these indictments from another dimension? Still, so sorry.

Expand full comment
Ally House (Oregon)'s avatar

My condolences on your loss.

Expand full comment
Rita Parker's avatar

Sending big hugs to you. I hope you have a strong support system. I have no doubt he would have loved all of this.

Expand full comment
Diana-Sedona's avatar

Condolences to you and your family!

Expand full comment
shee-rah's avatar

My deepest sympathy on the loss of your beloved husband.

Expand full comment
Marcia Sharkey's avatar

Same here. My husband passed on April 25. I pray he’s watching the craziness and helping any way he can to get us free of this horror of a human.

Expand full comment
SCS - Michigan's avatar

Marcia, hugs 🤗 to you!

Expand full comment
Harriet Buchanan's avatar

I'm so sorry for your loss, Marcia!

Expand full comment
Marcia Sharkey's avatar

Thanks so much, Harriet.

Expand full comment
Janet Carter's avatar

My deepest sympathies, Karen.

Expand full comment
Claudia McKelway's avatar

I am sorry for your loss Karen. I was fortunate to have my dad live until 96. He died late 2021 and we spent many an hour discussing all the horrific behavior. Never once was his faith in the American system of justice shaken. He would have been so happy to see these indictments rolling out.

Expand full comment
Tutone's avatar

And deepest condolences to you.

Expand full comment
SCS - Michigan's avatar

May Art’s memory be a blessing 💗

Expand full comment
Marlene Lerner-Bigley (CA)'s avatar

My best to you, Karen. I will keep you in my heart.

Expand full comment
Harriet Buchanan's avatar

Karen, I'm so sorry for your loss. My late husband and I used to follow politics closely, and I feel his loss acutely during this election season. It leaves a might dark hole in one's life.

Expand full comment
Barbara King's avatar

I’m not sure how sane I would be without your detailed Substack posts. You are clear, concise, and informative with a few cheeky phrases thrown in to keep it oh so enjoyable! Thank you, Joyce.

Expand full comment
D Deakin's avatar

Ahhh, yes, the cheeky phrases! I LIVE for those cheeky phrases!! Kinda like the icing on the cake, for me. I come for the knowledge, but stay for the sass!

Expand full comment
Michael Stayton's avatar

And the chickens. More please ....

Expand full comment
Louis Giglio's avatar

Brilliant! No one delivers ‘sass’ better than a wronged sister!

Expand full comment
Ally House (Oregon)'s avatar

Same, Barbara.

Expand full comment
Jettwomen's avatar

Totally agree...I have also learned a couple new words... keep that dictionary handy.

Expand full comment
ZsuzEB's avatar

Wow! Another bumpy week ahead. Thank you Joyce for the complete synopsis. But I don’t think TFG is going to shut his mouth anytime soon. Too many extra chances to continue to grift off his followers.

Continued peace and prayers for our country.☮️🙏🏼🙏🏼

Expand full comment
Tutone's avatar

This is exactly why we need to update many of our laws to protect the American people against a mob boss mentality of a sitting President such as 45 and update the constitution on originalism which to date has been grossly misinterpreted.

Expand full comment
Deb Pierce McCabe's avatar

Wouldn't spending some time in jail encourage the defendant to request a speedy trial? Win-win.

I don't know how anyone avoids drama with this guy. But if he's been warned not to threaten anyone associated with this trial (or be put in jail) and he's already making threats, then the court needs to follow through on its promises. I mean on its consequences. (Although it does feel like a promise to some of us.)

Expand full comment
Mimi Champlin's avatar

Not if he's using his "victimization" to pull in millions of donations. gigantic eye roll emoji here

Expand full comment
Deb Pierce McCabe's avatar

He'll do that anyway. He already is.

Expand full comment
Mimi Champlin's avatar

Agreed. When he's finally behind bars, the checks will double. I don't understand this insanity that surrounds him and always has, but I sure know the shape of it, as you've said, we KNOW what he's going to do. I feel it's a promise, as well, and one that damned well ought to be delivered on, if not for you and me specifically, for the entire country.

Expand full comment
Doug Smith's avatar

The madness of folks who would give up rent money and car payments to keep this satanic monster "billionaire" floating, is mind boggling. They see him as a fellow victim who is the mouthpiece for their miserable lives and victimhood. So weird.

Expand full comment
Tutone's avatar

45 wants to be put in jail to raise more money.

Expand full comment
Susan Burgess's avatar

Fine as long as it doesn’t delay his trial. And no phone.

Expand full comment
Linda McCaughey's avatar

Please tell me that Jack Smith has a whole lot of bodyguards surrounding him.

Expand full comment
Tutone's avatar

He surely does.

Expand full comment
Patricia Kvill's avatar

The media is once again giving Trump free publicity. Trump’s lawyer’s statements to the press are not evidence. This is not news. It’s simply “aspirational”. The media is just being lazy.

Expand full comment
T L Mills's avatar

....and greedy. Very, very greedy. And blindly stupid.

Expand full comment
Veronica Hruby's avatar

Joyce is one of a handful of voices these past few years, that have kept me sane and trusting that justice will prevail. If you’re not already, subscribe to #SisterInLaw podcast. 🤍

Expand full comment
Dianna Beers's avatar

LOVE the SIL podcast!

Expand full comment
Nancy Rhodes's avatar

Thanks for this clear explanation of the craziness! It sure does seem like Trump is trying to see how far he can push. I hope a gag order follows!

Expand full comment
Dianna Beers's avatar

Yes, he wants a gag order so he can scream about his first amendment rights being taken away from him.

Expand full comment
Doug Smith's avatar

On the flip side, letting the orange creep blab, helps incriminate him further. Think of how many lawyers have quit his cause and legal cases. His arrogance and mouth destroy any legal defense strategy.

Expand full comment
Annie D Stratton's avatar

However, he is likely to reveal the names of witnesses, thereby putting those people at risk. One reason he is not supposed to talk about things. I think the only thing that would keep him from doing that is the certainty that he would be in contempt of court and could very well end up in jail.

Expand full comment
Claudia McKelway's avatar

Excellent point

Expand full comment
ma-nyc's avatar

Thank you Joyce for giving us this legal briefing. It is because you so well prepare us that we so eagerly watch each event even during weekends.

Expand full comment
DianaR, SoCal's avatar

Again thank you Joyce. The Defendant’s comments are outrageous. I know it’s wishful thinking, but i wish Judge Chutkan would throw him him in jail to await trial sans McDonalds and his media megaphone. A few months with him in isolation would

Be good for everyone.

Expand full comment
Michael Stayton's avatar

And maybe a mental health evaluation

Expand full comment
Brian's avatar

Great summary of the weekend’s events lined up in order of occurrence. Thanks so much!

Expand full comment
SAH Vashon's avatar

This isn’t fun. It is not creative, intellectually stimulating or entertaining. Trump is torture. Thank you Joyce for your terrific writing and analysis. I am grateful for your passion for chickens and the law❤️!

Expand full comment
Claudia McKelway's avatar

And her knitting!

Expand full comment
SAH Vashon's avatar

Oh, yes!

Expand full comment