We’ve been talking a lot about New York state courts lately for the obvious reason that Donald Trump’s first criminal trial, from among his four indictments, is taking place there. As I’ve been discussing the case on TV this week, it occurred to me that explaining something about them that confused me as a first-year law student might come in handy.
Several interesting matters in the records falsification/election interference trial when it finally begins in earnest on Monday. For one thing, I would expect to hear more of what the prosecution has up its sleeve in its opening statement in terms of evidence beyond what is now publicly known (or surmised). Then, there's the defense's opening statement which is not required and in fact, can be delayed until after the government presents its case. Considering the defendant, don't think that will happen. That "eye for an eye" business. Thing is though, the statements cannot be argumentative; they must be deal with facts. So, not sure this defense can actually meet that requirement --- under the circumstances. Wouldn't be surprised to see a bit of sparring, right off the bat. Come Tuesday, would expect the defendant to get his ears pinned back by Judge Merchan following the gag order violation evidentiary hearing which is required. The defendant may well be fined but what a future violation punishment/deterrent might be will likely be far more severe. Merchan has to let Trump know who's in charge in no uncertain terms.
Wow NYS courts are weird with their terms. But on a different note, the best meme I’ve seen today is song lyrics. “Ain’t no sunshine till he’s gone, till he’s gone and locked away. Ain’t no sunshine till he’s gone and it’s taken too damn long! Get it done and do it today.” Now that song is stuck in your head and you’re welcome. 😁
Thank you for the explanation of what New York courts are called. I remembered that some of the trial courts were supreme courts, but forgot what the appellate courts were called. Now I don't have to do the research. You are the BEST!
Thank you so much for explaining the terms, which are confusing. Especially with so many trials going on, including the Federal trials coming up, the New York criminal trial starting, the civil fraud trial in New York, and the Georgia RICO case, which I'd like to hear more about as well. I don't know how any of us who are not lawyers could ever follow all of these cases without your guidance and explanations, along with the insights from Andrew Weissman, Neal Katyal, Barb McQuade and others. I so appreciate you!
I remember as Trump was desperately attempting to delay his January 6th trial not too many people were talking about how that would open up a "space" for this Manhattan trial, which many said was the least consequential of all four indictments Trump is/was facing. Well, look at him now. Aside from he can't seem to stay awake for 8 hours a day (he was always considered LAZY while in office - showing up to the "Oval Office" around noonish - it appears this trial is looking more and more serious to our TWICE IMPEACHED so-called two time popular vote LOSING four times indicted (ex) president. It's true, there's no guarantee the trial will end with a conviction - but sitting there for EIGHT weeks while President Biden continues CAMPAIGNING will not be a good look for Trump. Here's the "kicker." It appears shortly after this trial is over that DC Trial he's done everything he could to postpone will be moving toward commencing. Judge Chutkin has reportedly cleared her calendar for August - September. As the saying goes, "Be careful what you wish for."
Joyce, or others knowledgeable, how is the official record made in NY’s First Department? Court reporters, digital recording, voice recognition? Other?
Thank you for explaining the names of the courts in the state. It is very confusing!
Civil discourse because we are in it together.
RICO because they are in it together.
All I can say is “Finally!” At long last, someone is telling spoiled little Donny “No!”
Joyce, thank you for this explanation! You really enrich us with your clear information, helping us get through all this with such support.
Several interesting matters in the records falsification/election interference trial when it finally begins in earnest on Monday. For one thing, I would expect to hear more of what the prosecution has up its sleeve in its opening statement in terms of evidence beyond what is now publicly known (or surmised). Then, there's the defense's opening statement which is not required and in fact, can be delayed until after the government presents its case. Considering the defendant, don't think that will happen. That "eye for an eye" business. Thing is though, the statements cannot be argumentative; they must be deal with facts. So, not sure this defense can actually meet that requirement --- under the circumstances. Wouldn't be surprised to see a bit of sparring, right off the bat. Come Tuesday, would expect the defendant to get his ears pinned back by Judge Merchan following the gag order violation evidentiary hearing which is required. The defendant may well be fined but what a future violation punishment/deterrent might be will likely be far more severe. Merchan has to let Trump know who's in charge in no uncertain terms.
Wow NYS courts are weird with their terms. But on a different note, the best meme I’ve seen today is song lyrics. “Ain’t no sunshine till he’s gone, till he’s gone and locked away. Ain’t no sunshine till he’s gone and it’s taken too damn long! Get it done and do it today.” Now that song is stuck in your head and you’re welcome. 😁
Thank you for the explanation of what New York courts are called. I remembered that some of the trial courts were supreme courts, but forgot what the appellate courts were called. Now I don't have to do the research. You are the BEST!
MONDAY, Monday
In the urban maze, where legal battles blaze,
New York’s courts, a bewildering phase.
Supreme Court at the base, Appeals Court up high,
In this inverted reality, the chaos never dies!
Trump stands trial, a scene to catch,
Under Judge Merchan’s watch, a narrative to snatch.
But hold, what’s this? A claim of immunity?
To the U.S. Supreme Court, a dramatic journey!
Interlocutory orders, a phrase so grand,
Trump’s attorneys launch appeals, stirring the land.
"A fair trial in Manhattan? Impossible!" they bellow,
While the judge’s temper thins, his gavel poised to echo.
The Appellate Division, a brief stopping place,
Where Trump might gamble, in this legal race.
But the Court of Appeals may just decline,
Unless fresh dilemmas arise, calling for a review divine.
The jurors are ready, the trial about to start,
Trump’s lawyers digging deep, their defense an art.
But Judge Merchan stands firm, no more time to spare,
Opening statements on Monday, let the drama flare!
Here we stand, at the tempest’s core,
New York’s courts, a saga to adore.
Will Trump’s destiny be decided, in this legal showdown?
Time alone will reveal, in this courtroom battleground!
Secure your spot and brace for impact,
In New York’s courts, where facts are compact.
An untamed, tumultuous ride, in this Trumpian event,
With unexpected twists, bound to augment!
I’m aware the current trial is in NYC but, am I the only one waiting on the Georgia case to get in gear?
I am really looking forward to the contest between Ms Willis and the Trump for hire guys,.
C’mon Man!
Long range ( 6 week) NYC weather forecast = “Stormy” with the odd hurricane 🌀 and cyclone 🌀.
Potential tsunami 😂😂😂😂
Thank you so much for explaining the terms, which are confusing. Especially with so many trials going on, including the Federal trials coming up, the New York criminal trial starting, the civil fraud trial in New York, and the Georgia RICO case, which I'd like to hear more about as well. I don't know how any of us who are not lawyers could ever follow all of these cases without your guidance and explanations, along with the insights from Andrew Weissman, Neal Katyal, Barb McQuade and others. I so appreciate you!
I remember as Trump was desperately attempting to delay his January 6th trial not too many people were talking about how that would open up a "space" for this Manhattan trial, which many said was the least consequential of all four indictments Trump is/was facing. Well, look at him now. Aside from he can't seem to stay awake for 8 hours a day (he was always considered LAZY while in office - showing up to the "Oval Office" around noonish - it appears this trial is looking more and more serious to our TWICE IMPEACHED so-called two time popular vote LOSING four times indicted (ex) president. It's true, there's no guarantee the trial will end with a conviction - but sitting there for EIGHT weeks while President Biden continues CAMPAIGNING will not be a good look for Trump. Here's the "kicker." It appears shortly after this trial is over that DC Trial he's done everything he could to postpone will be moving toward commencing. Judge Chutkin has reportedly cleared her calendar for August - September. As the saying goes, "Be careful what you wish for."
I was banned from “truth social” for saying DJT is a narcissist 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 I wear it as a badge of honour 👨⚖️
Joyce, or others knowledgeable, how is the official record made in NY’s First Department? Court reporters, digital recording, voice recognition? Other?
Thank you for explaining the names of the courts in the state. It is very confusing!
Thank you. I will keep this one handy to get the nomenclature straight.
Excellent. I'll be popping corn every day of the trial. I yield back my time.
FINALLY "We're going to have opening statements on Monday morning. This trial is starting." So, sit down, shut up, nap all ya want fpotus 😈